The Cascading Impact of Distrust in the C-Suite

The Cascading Effects of Trust Deficiency in Organizations

Consider for a moment the dynamics at play within any organization. At the highest levels, executives set the tone and culture for the entire organization. Their actions, decisions, and communication styles ripple down through the hierarchy, influencing attitudes and behaviours across all teams. Addressing executive trust issues can dramatically improve organizational alignment.

When trust is strong among C-suite leaders it creates a compelling sense of unity and direction. High trust on a leadership team looks like this:

• Team members feel comfortable sharing their ideas, concerns, and feedback.
• There’s a sense of alignment and shared purpose.
• Executives feel safe to voice dissenting opinions or challenge the status quo without fear of retribution.
• The ELT engages in healthy discussions to resolve differences instead of allowing them to escalate into personal conflicts or unresolved tensions.

Conversely, when distrust surfaces the effects can create a domino effect that impacts every level of the organization. Low trust on executive teams looks like this:

• ELT members are withholding information or avoiding sharing their thoughts.
• Silos and disconnection have developed.
• Defensive communication and/or behaviour is frequent.
• Team members feel unsupported or undervalued.

The most sobering reality about this is how a lack of strong trust at the top advances issues that cascade throughout the organization. From decision-making inefficiencies to declining employee morale, the implications are significant.

By understanding these dynamics, leaders can take proactive steps to cultivate a culture of trust, ensuring that their organizations are positioned for resilience and growth. Let’s look first at how this devolution occurs, and then how to build back up.

‍

The Foundation of Trust in the C-Suite

Many CEOs believe there is strong trust on their Executive Leadership Team (ELT), however, confidential team member feedback often reveals a different story. Underlying tensions, miscommunications, or unaddressed conflicts that undermine the perceived cohesion—these factors are ultimately affecting leadership’s decision-making and overall organizational performance.

As C-level executives, we hold the keys to our organization’s culture. Think about the leaders who inspire you—they likely embody transparency, openness, respect, and consistency. These traits are the bedrock of a trusting environment. But what happens when distrust creeps into the C-suite? Executives begin to hoard information or prioritize their personal agendas over collective goals. It’s like a game of chess where everyone plays for themselves—confusion rules, decisions become muddled, and strategic misalignment leads the organization into murky waters.

Real-World Example: Consider a company during a digital transformation. If the CEO and CTO can’t align on the technology strategy, the rest of the teams will be left guessing. Are we moving forward with a new software? Is the budget secure? Uncertainty breeds hesitation, and that’s where potential innovation goes to die.

How does this start to go wrong?

‍

The Initial Breakdown: Signs of C-Suite Distrust

Let’s paint a vivid picture: You’re in a tech firm where sales are plummeting (a common trigger for high-stakes, high-emotion dialogue), and instead of uniting to confront this pressing issue, the executive team is like a house divided.

Tension fills the meeting; some executives believe the answer lies in aggressive marketing strategies, while others advocate for a complete overhaul of the product line. Instead of engaging in constructive debate, each faction digs in, defending their territory and dismissing the ideas of their colleagues.

There’s a pervasive sense of futility around making any innovative suggestions—team members think, “Why bother? The CEO won’t listen,” leading to a culture of disengagement. Meetings drag on without resolution, as discussions become circular and unproductive. The few suggestions that do emerge receive only half-hearted buy-in, as executives are more focused on protecting their own positions than collaborating for the greater good.

Clarity of direction? Forget about it. With conflicting agendas and a lack of trust, no one is sure which path to follow, leading to confusion among middle management and frontline employees who are left to navigate the uncertainty.

Even if a decision is reached, the ‘us-vs-them’ mindset is further entrenched. Everyone leaves the meeting like opposing teams from a sports field, some triumphant at “winning”, some fuming over the lack of receptiveness to the ideas they advocated for, some demoralized by the whole situation, some bracing for departmental backlash, some fearing for their jobs.

‍

The Ripple Effect Through Management Layers

The result? A toxic mix of disengagement and low morale. This kind of environment breeds fear and apprehension, making it challenging for anyone to feel confident in their roles.

• VPs are resigned to not having their input valued, and stop bothering to offer it.
• This perception cascades to the Manager level as they take cues from their leaders and stop seeking ideas and feedback from their teams.
• Employees begin to disengage, feeling like they are merely cogs in a dysfunctional machine.

The overall impact is detrimental: innovation stalls, morale dips, top talent leaves for greener pastures, taking invaluable skills and knowledge with them, and the organization risks losing not just sales but also its competitive edge in the market.

Now, let’s shift our focus to middle management—the unsung heroes often caught in the crossfire of executive distrust. These managers are desperately trying to implement strategies while barely getting clear directives from above. A manager who senses the tension among executives might hesitate to fully back a new initiative, fearing it may lead their team down the wrong path, leaving them open to a blame culture backlash.

But here’s the silver lining: strong middle management can be a game changer! When these leaders embrace a culture of trust and transparent communication, they can bridge the gap between the chaos at the top and the teams on the ground. They’re the ones who can transform executive vision into actionable steps, ensuring their teams feel supported and aligned.

Real-World Example: Amidst executive chaos, a manufacturing plant manager takes the initiative to hold open forums with their team, encouraging candid discussions. This not only boosts morale but also sparks innovative ideas that can propel the organization forward—ideas that might have been lost in the executive shuffle.

How fortunate for organizations that have fantastic middle managers who are mitigating some of the damage cascading down from the C-suite! But they can’t hold the wall forever; if the problems at the top are not resolved, employee engagement and performance will begin to plummet.

The Impact of Leadership Distrust on Employee Engagement and Culture

As distrust seeps deeper into the organization, the effects on employee morale can be dramatic. When team members feel their leaders are at odds, they may disengage entirely.

Real-World Example: A retail company’s leaders are in conflict and indecisive. The employees see them squabbling and feel disconnected and unmoored as the answers and plans keep being delayed or changed back and forth. They end up feeling apathetic, leading to a decline in customer service and satisfaction.

But here’s the flip side: organizations that prioritize trust and open communication tend to flourish, gaining the true power of their employees.

Real-World Example: A distribution company was struggling to adapt to dynamic market changes. After years of internal conflict, they decided enough was enough and committed to rebuilding trust through transparency. The result? Empowered employees began to share creative ideas, leading to innovations that revitalized the company and improved its market position.

‍

The Long-Term Effects of Trust and Distrust on Organizational Performance

The long-term impact of mistrust can be staggering. Companies plagued by low trust often see performance metrics plummet. Productivity dips, turnover rates skyrocket, and customer satisfaction nosedives.

Real-World Example: A financial institution neglects to cultivate trust and finds its employees disinterested in providing excellent service. Every new employee who comes on soon experiences the same negative effects, leading to high turnover, exhaustion from the loyal core, and ultimately harming customer loyalty and the bottom line.

On the flip side, organizations that invest in trust-building strategies consistently outperform their competitors.

Real-World Example: A tech startup embraced transparency from day one, establishing a bold precedent for open communication by sharing both successes and challenges with all team members. This commitment fostered a culture of trust, attracting and retaining top talent who valued an environment where their voices could be heard and contributions recognized. Empowered to propose bold solutions and challenge the status quo, employees were excited to experiment and innovate. Cross-functional collaboration flourished as teams worked together to tackle complex problems, enabling the startup to adapt quickly to market changes and seize new opportunities. As its reputation for integrity and ethical practices grew, so did its client base, creating a virtuous cycle of success.

By prioritizing transparency and trust from the outset, this tech startup not only cultivated a thriving workplace but also built a resilient ecosystem that drove sustainable growth and positioned it for long-term success.

‍

Strategies for Rebuilding Trust Throughout the Organization

So, how can you kickstart the journey toward rebuilding trust in your organization? Here are a few approachable strategies:

1. Embrace Transparency: Share your vision openly and encourage ongoing dialogue. Let your team know they’re in the loop—this will foster a sense of belonging and commitment.
2. Leadership Training: Invest in training focused on trust-building. Equip your fellow leaders (and yourself!) with the skills needed to model trust in actions and communications. Start with the ELT, but also look to key leaders throughout the organization.
3. Involve Employees: Engage your team in decision-making processes. When employees feel their voices matter, they’re more likely to invest in the company’s success. Regular feedback sessions can cultivate a culture of accountability and openness. Be sure to listen deeply and fully consider the input.

‍

A Real-World Example of Building Trust in the Workforce and Leadership  

Let’s look at a public example: Cisco Systems. They’ve successfully transformed the organizational culture by emphasizing transparency and employee involvement.

Cisco maintains open communication channels, regularly shares updates on financial performance, strategic goals, and operational challenges through town hall meetings and internal platforms. This practice fosters trust and keeps employees informed about the company’s direction. Additionally, Cisco promotes financial transparency, empowering employees to understand how their roles contribute to overall success.

To further encourage employee involvement, Cisco has established ‘employee resource groups’ that allow staff to connect based on shared interests and experiences, fostering inclusion and collaboration. The company also invites employees to participate in innovation programs, such as the “Cisco Innovation Challenge,” where they can pitch ideas for improvement. Regular feedback mechanisms help leadership respond to employee needs, enhancing engagement and motivation.

This focus on transparency and involvement has led to a more committed workforce, driving collaboration and innovation while solidifying Cisco's position as a leader in the technology sector.

‍

Start with Yourself: Executive Leadership Team Trust

As C-level executives, the onus is on us to actively cultivate an environment where trust flourishes.

Rebuilding trust is a journey that requires time, intention, and commitment. But the dividends are substantial—a more engaged workforce, a culture of collaboration, and enhanced performance metrics. These are not just abstract benefits, they translate into tangible outcomes, the kind that help us sleep at night and feel excited and hopeful for our organization’s future.

But doing this work is our responsibility. We must commit to leading by example, demonstrating transparency, accountability, and open communication in all our interactions. By prioritizing trust-building strategies, we are not just reinforcing the structural integrity of our organizations, we are setting the foundation for sustainable long-term success.

We encourage you to consider the state of trust in your executive team, challenge unhealthy norms, and even consider getting some confidential feedback surveys done for your team. Getting a true benchmark for where safe-guards or relational investment or coaching could be directed is often the first step towards building high trust in your team, and doing so can transform the performance of your whole organization.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the signs of low trust in a leadership team?

Common indicators include withholding important information, frequent defensive or combative communication, noticeable lack of alignment on decisions, and leaders prioritizing personal agendas over collective goals. Over time, these behaviours create silos, fuel internal conflicts, and cause team members to feel unsupported or undervalued.

How does executive distrust affect employee engagement?

When distrust exists among executives, employees quickly sense instability, leading to uncertainty about their roles and hesitance to fully engage or innovate. Over time, this creates a cycle of apathy, declining morale, and increased turnover as talented employees seek healthier work environments elsewhere.

How can leaders rebuild organizational trust?

Leaders can rebuild trust by consistently modeling transparency, openly sharing information, and actively inviting feedback from all organizational levels. Investing in trust-focused leadership training, addressing conflicts proactively, and demonstrating genuine accountability in both decision-making and communication are essential steps toward restoring a healthy workplace culture.